I'll do my best to delete items from this list as needed, but it might not always be completely accurate.

9th Birthday Luxury Cake
9th Birthday Pearl
Acorn Gumball
Acorn Pearl
American Flag Gummy
American Hot Dog
Angel Cake
Angel Potato
Anime Potato
Anjet Poop
Aquarius Water
Australian Potato
Autumn Ice Cream
Azul Easter Egg
Baby Pearl
Bae Candy Heart
Bag of Chocolate Coins
Balloon Pearl
Banana Freezie
Bankrupt Pearl
Banofee Pie
Battle Arena Easter Egg
Battle Fairy Sugar Cube
Battle Gumball
Beach Pearl
Beanberry Sundae
Bearger
Bee Pearl
Bellerina Jelly
Biala Easter Egg
Black and White Easter Egg
Black Blood
Black Bunns
Black DNA
Black Easter Egg
Black Forest Cake
Black Gummi
Black Potato Chips
Black Sorry Candy Heart
Black Yolk
Blitzen Easter Egg
Blitzen Pearl
Blitzen Potato
Bloody Potato
Blue Bunns
Blue DNA
Blue Easter Egg
Blue Gummi
Blue Potato
Blue Yolk
Blueberry Duo Popsicle
Blueberry Freezie
Blueberry Icicle
Blueberry Shell Candy
Bolimo Easter Egg
Bone Potato
Boot Camp Sugar Cube
Bootleg Cherries
Bootleg Pearl
Bottled Storm
Bounchy Jelly
Breakfast
Broken Egg Pearl
Bronze Easter Egg
Brown Bunns
Brown DNA
Brown Easter Egg
Brown Gummi
Brown Yolk
Bug Candy
Bunns
Burnt Pearl
Burnt Pokey
Burnt Potato
Burnt Potato Chips
Burnt Sugar Pie
Butter Popcorn
Buttered Potato
Cabbachi
Calico Potato
Camouflage Pearl
Camouflage Potato
Candy Crunch Cereal
Candy Gumball
Candytree Easter Egg
Carrot Juice Pouch
Caspule
Chagon
Charm Me Candy Heart
Checkered Potato
Cheese Fries
Cheesy Gumball
Cheesy Potato
Chepiz
Cherg
Cherry Pies
Cherub Poop
Chibaccino
Chibs Easter Egg
Chibs Ice Sculpture
Chlug
Choat
Chocolate Beach Cake
Chocolate Cherry
Chocolate Cornet
Chocolate Duo Popsicle
Chocolate Easter Egg
Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Love Pie
Chocolate Pearl
Christmas Pearl
Christmas Pretzel
Christmas Vanilla Pudd

I've been keeping a spreadsheet of all my results on both plushie machines and figured at least one or two people might be interested in the results, now that I've reached an even 1000 results on both. I do them both at the same time, always choose the same direction (About 100 attempts I moved left for both, but for all the other results, I've moved up.)

Here are the totals..

Dropped plushies:
regular machine - 256 dropped plushies
enchanted machine - 172 dropped plushies

Unenchanted plushies:
regular machine - 348 unenchanted plushies
enchanted machine - 317 unenchanted plushies

MP:
regular machine - 343 mp prizes (totaling 52,283mp)
enchanted machine - 457 mp prizes (totaling 337,502mp; 13 of the results were over 1,000mp with the highest being 28,722)

and finally, Enchanted plushies:
regular machine - 53 enchanted plushies
enchanted machine - 54 enchanted plushies (1 of which was LE)