Rarity 12: You dipped Black Leido Plushie into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Poison Cider!

Rarity 15:You dipped 8th Birthday Cupcake into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Poison Pie!

Rarity 5:You dipped Addow in a Barrel into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Tiger Skin!

Rarity 7:You dipped Bubble Pipe into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Poisoned Potato!

Rarity 1:You dipped Blue Gumball into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Poison Drink!

Rarity 7:You dipped Angel Candy Heart into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Spiked Pear!

Rarity 3:You dipped Rock Gumball into the Poison Pit and...
It's now Oily Skin!